termitis
November 24, 2009, 1:46 pm
[quote name='Craig Sheffield' post='945923' date='Nov 21 2009, 09:02 PM']Well, its a funny thing you should say that. I rarely drive the wifes 1.4D. But when I did (when I had my previous Diesel), I always felt it was actually quite rapid.
I have now had the 1.8 for around 7 weeks (after 4 years of driving diesels). Today I took both cars to the hand carwash. So its the first drive of hers since having my SR. My thoughts, oh my god its sluggish in 1st & 2nd....of course it isnt actually, its just now I am used to driving using all the rev range.
However in 3rd/4th there is so so so much more torque in the 1.4 than mine, its just delivers the power so effortlessly up to 70. The 1.8 is a different beast, the roar/squeeling of the VVTI at 4-6k revs is simply lovely, and it gets there quicker I think, but the delivery of the diesel just feels quicker at say 40-70
Once at 70 though the diesel is actually quieter than the 1.8, due to 70-80 only being around 2.5k revs, the 1.8 at 80 is about 3.5k.
It really depends on what driving you do, the 1.8 plainly is a more rapid car though the entire rev range, its far nipper in town traffic, you dont really have to think about things, the diesel like all TDi's you really have to have the turbo running before you can boot it, for overtaking drop the 1.8 into 3rd and it will happily fly.
Not sure on the gearing on the Tdi, but to give an idea, the 1.8 SR is setup as follows (IIRC from the manual)
1st Gear - 31mph
2nd Gear - 56mph
3rd Gear - 86mph (awsome gearage here for overtaking caravans/lorries/tractors on A roads)
4th Gear - 106mph
5th Gear - to limiter
If you want to compare to a performance diesel, I previously had a 1.9 Tdi (150psi) Seat Leon FR and 3rd gear was 81mpg. I miss the torque of that car (263lbs), but having to always judge the turbo, was a nightmare.
Oh and this week I have done 200 miles, and the trip comp has now said I have 70 left, so I am 20mile up on what I have previously been averaging on the dash
[quote name='termitis' post='945914' date='Nov 21 2009, 06:38 PM']WE need a 1.8 RS VS 1.4 d4d review!!!!!!![/quote]
[/quote]
thanks!!!!
i have a 2009 d4d 6 speed

great engine