Hi all, A very delayed response but I had a similar problem on my '59 plate Aygo Blue. When I turned on the right indicator it would not turn on, or would only flash once and would never 'click' into the indicating motion. I would regularly have to hold it up whilst indicating, it was a nightmare! However when indicating left, it was fine. The bulbs were all fine as well, and would flash in time, as long as I was holding the stalk up. Anyway, I took it to Toyota, who took it for tests and they immediately came back and said they had 'condemned the stalk' itself. They ordered me a new one and fitted it under warranty. It's been perfect ever since. However, considering the speed with which they condemned it, and the apparent awareness they had when I explained the issue, I would suggest it's a common issue with Aygo's unfortunately!