Food for thought, a quote from Pistonheads forum 3 years ago - “The biggest problem with them is that they let all the soot and rubbish from the exhaust clog up the inlet. This not only lowers performance but makes the emissions worse and reduces engine life - it's a fantastic own goal by the environmentalists. They may work OKish when the engine is new but after just 10,000 miles they can clog up, fail to close properly, waste boost pressure, increase emissions etc Black it off and if possible, clean the inlet manifold - your engine will run much smoother, quieter, be more economical and make the same power it ought to have done and the emissions will be lower than with a clogged up, dirty, leaking engine. I believe they were fitted as a result of an EU directive, a political solution to a problem which didn't exist rather than an engineering solution to a genuine problem”. Back to me - I did not see the parts list of my cars modification and I have had no problems since. If your problem persists perhaps you did need a new EGR valve all along